Who is the Biggest Casting Mistake in The Lord of the Rings?

The casting of The Lord of the Rings film trilogy has been the subject of extensive discussion, with many viewers and critics highlighting several key instances where their expectations of the characters did not match the final results. Among these, the most prominent and debated casting choices involve Aragorn, Frodo, and Samwise Gamgee. Each of these characters bears unique expectations from the source material, and the casting can dramatically alter the audience's experience.

The Case of Aragorn

One of the most frequently discussed casting decisions is that of Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn. While many fans loved Mortensen in his roles, the physicality and accent of his performance were seen as inconsistent with the ideal portrayal of Aragorn. Critics often point out that his appearance is more stumpy, which detracted from the elvish blood he is believed to have. Additionally, Mortensen's Oklahoma twang accent was not fitting with the character's presumed noble heritage.

Alternative choices such as Clive Owen, known for his elegance and physical presence, would have been more fitting. Owen's height, demeanor, and accent match the refined and sturdy figure of a royal heir. His casting could have enhanced the overall aesthetic harmony of the film's cast and framework.

Samwise Gamgee

A second frequently mentioned casting choice is that of Sean Astin as Samwise Gamgee. While Astin's portrayal of the character has been widely beloved, some critics argue that his physical appearance does not match J.R.R. Tolkien's description of Sam as a robust, sturdy figure. Critics often point to Astin's slender build and youthful features as not fully capturing the essence of the loyal and stalwart Hobbit.

Sean Astin was 19 years old during The Lord of the Rings trilogy, which some argue is too young for the character's depth and maturity. Many fans and critics feel that a larger, more physically imposing actor might have better conveyed Sam's strength and dedication to his friends and the Fellowship as a whole.

Frodo Baggins

Another notable casting choice that has faced significant criticism is Elijah Wood as Frodo Baggins. Despite Wood's ability to handle a weighty responsibility in his performance, many viewers and critics feel that his portrayal does not fully capture the depth and gravitas required for the role.

Frodo is a character of immense responsibility, carrying the burden of the One Ring and facing numerous challenges. The original book describes Frodo as a leader and a person of great courage and determination. However, some feel that Wood's performance was somewhat lackluster, portraying Frodo more as a follower rather than a leader. The character's potential to inspire and lead his Fellowship is diminished in Wood's portrayal.

A Dream Cast Revisited

Considering the shortcomings in the aforementioned cast choices, a reimagined dream cast for select characters would enhance the overall experience of the The Lord of the Rings trilogy. For Lobelia Sackville Baggins, the role could have been better filled by actress Barbara Leigh-Hunt, known for her strong presence and dramatic roles.

For Denethor, the role could have been ideal for Charles Dance, who brings a commanding and nuanced performance to historical and fantasy roles. Similarly, Galadriel could have been enhanced with an even younger, more ethereal interpretation by Vanessa Redgrave.

The casting of Aragorn could have been improved by Daniel Day-Lewis, who is renowned for his ability to fully embody a character. His profound acting skills would have brought a more profound and noble character to the film. Faramir might also have benefited from Jon Finch’s performance, who could have added a layer of moral depth and vulnerable leadership that the character desperately needed.

Samwise Gamgee could have been more fitting with a kind-eyed, British actor like James Corden. Instead of the character's perceived timidity, Corden would bring a warmth and resilience that aligns better with the character's genuine concern and strength.

The role of Frodo Baggins could have been reimagined with Peter Dinklage, who, at 33, would have better captured the mature and noble presence required for the character.

To round out the dream cast, Theoden could have been better played by a younger, more vulnerably aged actor like John Gielgud or Patrick Stewart, and Barliman Butterburr could be brought to life more convincingly by Robbie Coltrane.

The cast for Eowyn could benefit from a fierce, robust interpretation by actress Charlize Theron in plaits, capturing the warrior and the queen in one iconic role.

These reimagined casting choices would not only enhance the visual and narrative aspects of The Lord of the Rings but also bring a more authentic and compelling experience to the viewers.